Music 344—Encounter 1
The Classical Era:  Classical Instrumental Music—Classic Vocal Music & Opera
Readings
Symphony Research Project
Paper Topics
Listening Assignment 1
Sonata Form Listening Guide
Extra Credit Listening
Due Date: Monday, February 13, 2012

Readings—

  • J. Peter Burkholder, A History of Western Music
    • Chapter 20—Musical Taste and Style in the Enlightenment, pp. 468-482
    • Chapter 21—Opera and Vocal Music in the Early Classic Period, pp. 483-505
    • Chapter 22—Instrumental Music: Sonata, Symphony, and Concerto at Midcentury, pp. 506-525
    • Chapter 23—Classic Music in the Late Eighteenth Century, pp. 526-565
  • J. Peter Burkholder, Norton Anthology of Western Music, Vol. 2 (NAWM)
    • NAWM 101-17, pp. 1-271
  • Nancy Baker. “The Aesthetic Theories of Heinrich Christoph Koch.” International Review of the Aesthetics and Sociology of Music, Vol. 8, No. 2, 183-209 (see .pdf on Blackboard RESERVE).
    Read from the bottom of p. 184 to p. 192.
  • Heinrich Christoph Koch. From Introductory Essay on Composition (1782-93) in Source Readings in Music History: The Late Eighteenth Century, ed. by Wye J. Allanbrook, 780.9 S927s 1998 v.5 (Library and Blackboard RESERVE). Read pp. 73-78 (“On the Symphony ”)
  • Reinhard G. Pauly. Music in the Classical Period. Prentice Hall, 1965, 780.9033 P333m (Library and Blackboard RESERVE). Read Chapter 3, The Pre-Classic Symphony, pp. 37-42 (the section titled “Sonata Form”) and Chapter 6, The Classic Symphony, pp. 98-113.
  • Richard J. Wingell, Writing about Music, 3rd ed. Prentice Hall, 2002, 808.06678 W956w 2002 (Library and Blackboard RESERVE). Reach Chapter 1, Writing about Music, pp. 1-8, and Chapter 2, Analysis and Research, pp. 9-20
Return to top
 

I. Classical Symphony Research Project

The ability to provide readable, meaningful written analysis of a musical work is an essential skill for any musician. Since analysis of one kind or another serves as the basis for most writing on music, it will serve as the focus for our first written assignment. Later assignments will ask you to address different audiences, but they all require you to say intelligent things about music!

This first project focuses on the history, theory, and musical form of one of the sonata-form Classical symphony movements listed below. Your written paper will emerge from your work in these four areas:

  • Biographical research
  • Analysis of theoretical treatises
  • Active listening
  • Score analysis

Process

I. Choose one of the following Classical symphonies for this project! (Musical scores & recordings are available on Blackboard.)

  1. Haydn, Symphony No. 45 in F-sharp Minor (Farewell), H. I/45 (1772)—mvmt. I
  2. Mozart, Symphony No. 29 in A Major, K. 201/186a (1774)—mvmt. I
  3. Mozart, Symphony No. 40 in G Minor, K. 550 (1788)—mvmt. I or mvmt. IV for this work
  4. Mozart, Symphony No. 41 in C Major (Jupiter), K. 551 (1788)—mvmt. I
  5. Haydn, Symphony No. 104 in D Major (London), H. I/104 (1795)—mvmt. I

II. Research the historical and theoretical concepts that define the late 18th-century symphony in general and your specific Classical symphony in particular. The following four required readings (also listed above under Readings) will help you answer the questions in parts III and IV:

  1. Nancy Baker. “The Aesthetic Theories of Heinrich Christoph Koch” (Blackboard RESERVE). Read pp. 184-192.
  2. Heinrich Christoph Koch. From Introductory Essay on Composition (1782-93) in Source Readings in Music History: The Late Eighteenth Century (Library & Blackboard RESERVE). Read pp. 73-78 (“On the Symphony ”).
  3. Reinhard G. Pauly. Music in the Classical Period (Library & Blackboard RESERVE). Read pp. 37-42 and 98-113.
  4. Richard J. Wingell, Writing about Music (Library and Blackboard RESERVE). Reach pp. 1-8 (on writing about music) and pp. 9-20 (on writing musical analysis—once you get past p. 13, focus especially on the Mozart example on p. 16)

***In addition, research the location and date of your symphony's premiere within the article for your composer at Oxford Music Online (available electronically through the library website)

III. Write short-response answers to the following questions

  1. What musical features does H.C. Koch focus on in his descrption of the “first Allegro” (first-movement, or sonata form)? Why doesn’t he use terms like Exposition, Development, or Recapitulation? How does he describe these sections? (Burkholder provides further insight into Koch’s ideas on textbook pp. 512-14, and so does Pauly on pp. 37-42.)
  2. Koch argues that an excellent composition includes elements of unity and variety (multiplicity). Please explain the closer details of this theory from Koch.
  3. Not all 18th-century music theorists praised instrumental genres like the symphony or the concerto. According to Koch, why did certain theorists (especially Johann Georg Sulzer) criticize these genres?
  4. Detail the historical significance of your selected symphony. How many symphonies did your chosen composer write? When, where, and by whom was your symphony premiered?

IV. Close Analysis—First, outline the formal structure of the symphony movement you selected. These are all sonata-form movements, so you have several models to draw on when you make your chart. You can use the listening guides for sonata-form symphony movements in NAWM (109, 112a, or 116 work well), or you can use the arch and tonal maps in the Sonata Form Listening Guide below. Your analytical chart should include keys and key changes and label important melodic motives and themes present in the movement (with measure numbers for each). Then write at least a 2-paragraph listening guide that highlights important features of the form.

  • Pay special attention to interesting or unusual features of your work, especially:
    • How the Development section uses and develops themes from the Exposition
    • Important differences between the Expositon and the Recapitulation, especially in their transitions from Theme 1 to Theme 2
    • Introduction and Coda (if present) and their relation to the body of the work
  • In what ways is your chosen symphony movement typical or atypical? Explain.

What to turn in—

  • Please submit your project in a two-part paper:
    1. Short Answers to Questions 1-4 (in part III above)
    2. Analysis of your chosen symphony movement (as per part IV above)
  • Your written comments should fill about 2 pages.
  • Provide a “Works Cited” page (Bibliograhpy) at the end (on page 3).
    • Include an MLA format entry for the Blackboard score (or whichever score you used)
    • Include an MLA format entry (plus names of performers) for the Blackboard recording (or whichever recording you used)
    • List all consulted print sources in MLA format. Include the following:
      • the four required sources
      • Oxford Music Online (Grove Music Online, specifically)
      • Your textbooks (if you used them)
      • At least three more scholarly books or articles (perhaps a good article, biography, and/or period history?).
Return to top


II. Paper Preparation

Choose three possible topics for your final research paper. Write a brief abstract (one paragraph description) about each topic that sketches out some of your ideas for that topic. Click here for more information about the paper.

Return to top


Listening Assignment 1

Classical Instrumental Music, Vocal Music & Opera

The listening section on the Classicism Unit Exam will consist of several listening identification excerpts. All works on the Listening List below are fair game. Recordings are from NRAWM unless otherwise noted. For each work I play you will identify the following:
  • Composer, title, and movement
  • Genre—piano concerto? solo sonata? string quartet? symphony? intermezzo? opera buffa? opera seria? reform opera? dramma giocoso?
  • Form—
    • For instrumental works—binary? rondo? rounded binary? sonata form? ternary? theme & variations?
    • For operatic works—recitative (simple or accompanied?)? aria (da capo or other type?)? ensemble? chorus?
  • Style—early Classic (galant or empfindsam?) or late Classic?
  • Other important features as requested in questions drawn from Study Questions below
Each cluster of works below is accompanied by a set of Study Questions. The Study Questions and recordings together will help you prepare for the Classicism Unit Exam. They require no written report. For further info on features of sonata form, click here to see the Classic Sonata Form Listening Guide below. As always, you really want to read the NAWM notes and follow the score for every work from NRAWM.

Listening List

Early Classic Sonata & Concerto—Bach’s Sons

A) NAWM 107—Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach, Sonata in A Major, H. 186, Wq. 55/4 (Early Classic Sonata)

  • mvmt. ii: Poco adagio—CD7, tracks 28-29

B) NAWM 110—Johann Christian Bach, Concerto for Piano and Strings, Op. 7 no. 5 (Early Classic Concerto)

  • mvmt. i: Allegro di molto—CD7, tracks 38-46

Study Questions on A-B:

  • 1. Which work sounds like a good examples of galant style? Which one sounds like empfindsam style? What specific musical features helped you make your decisions.
  • 2. Which of these works has the most elaborate structure? How would you describe the overall form of each one?

The Classical Symphony

Early Classic Symphonies

C) NAWM 108—Giovanni Battista Sammartini, Symphony in F Major, No. 32 (Early Classic Symphony)

  • mvmt. i: Presto—CD7, tracks 30-32

D) NAWM 109—Johann Wenzel Anton Stamitz, Sinfonia a 8 in E-flat Major (Early Classic Symphony)

  • mvmt. i: Allegro assai—CD7, tracks 33-37

Late Classic Symphonies

E) NAWM 112—Franz Joseph Haydn, Symphony No. 92 in G Major, “Oxford” (Late Classic Symphony)

  • mvmt. i: Adagio–Allegro spiritoso—CD7, tracks 52-61
  • mvmt. ii: Adagio cantabile—CD7, tracks 62-65
  • mvmt. iii: Menuetto Allegretto—CD7, tracks 66-70
  • mvmt. iv: Presto—CD7, tracks 71-79
    • Alternate Recording: Haydn, Cecilia Bartoli and Nikolaus Harnoncourt Live in Concert RESERVE DVD—VIDEO 782.1 C388

F) NAWM 116—Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Symphony No. 41 in C Major, “Jupiter,” K. 551 (Late Classic Symphony)

  • mvmt. iv: Finale. Molto allegro—CD8, tracks 27-35
    • Alternate Recording: Mozart, Symphonies 40 & 41 RESERVE DVD—VIDEO 780.92 M939

Study Questions on C-F:

  • 3. As you listen, use the analytical charts in NAWM and listen for the important features of sonata form in the three sonata-form movements above. Specifically, listen for these events: Exposition, Development, and Recapitulation as well as the four main themes within the Exposition (Theme 1, Bridge, Theme 2, & Closing Theme). Listen carefully to hear the differences in character between 1st Theme, Bridge, 2nd Theme, Closing Theme, and Development. For further info on features of sonata form, click here to see the Classic Sonata Form Listening Guide below. Hint: The Exposition ends at the repeat sign (except in the Stamitz which has no repeat signs—assume m. 74 is the end of the Exposition and the start of the Development. The three sonata-form movements are:
    • Stamitz, Sinfonia, mvmt. i
    • Haydn, Symphony No. 92, mvmt. i
    • Mozart, Symphony No. 41, mvmt. iv
  • 4. What differences do you hear when you compare early Classic symphonies (C-D) with late Classic symphonies (E-F)? Consider especially the instrumentation, length, and mood of these works. How did the early Classic works strike you? Were they interesting? boring? pleasant?
  • 5. Even though it is very short, did any features of the Sammartini Symphony remind you of sonata form?
  • 6. As you listened to the complete symphony above (E), how did the contrasts in the four-movement format add to your enjoyment? How did movements ii, iii, and iv differ from the 1st movement?
  • 7. Do any features or sections of Mozart’s Symphony No. 41, mvmt. iv, strike you as unusual or unusually dramatic (compared to the other Classical symphonies in NAWM)? How do you explain this?

Late Classic String Quartet, Sonata, & Concerto

G) NAWM 111—Franz Joseph Haydn, String Quartet Op. 33 no. 2 (The Joke) (Late Classic String Quartet)

  • mvmt. iv: Presto—CD7, tracks 47-51

H) NAWM 114—Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Piano Sonata in F Major, K. 332 (Late Classic Sonata)

  • mvmt. i: Allegro—CD8, tracks 1-8

I) NAWM 115—Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Piano Concerto in A Major, K. 488 (Late Classic Concerto)

  • mvmt. i: Allegro—CD8, tracks 9-26

Study Questions on G-I:

  • 8. How would you describe the effect of the rondo form Haydn uses in the last movement of this String Quartet (G). How does Haydn “play” with the return of the rondo theme (Refrain)? Does this movement make an effective ending for a four-movement quartet or not? Why or why not?
  • 9. As you did with the symphony 1st movements above, use the NAWM chart so you can follow the main sections of sonata form in this Mozart sonata movement. Did the form of the C.P.E. Bach sonata resemble the full-blown sonata form of this Mozart movement in any way? Why or why not?
  • 10. How does this late Classic Mozart concerto (I) compare with the early Classic J.C. Bach Concerto you listened to above. What are the most interesting differences between them? Look at the NAWM diagram for this work. Compared with the symphony diagrams you looked at earlier, what’s odd about Mozart’s concerto 1st movement Exposition? or his Development?

Early Classic Opera

J) NAWM 101—Giovanni Battista Pergolesi, La serva padrona (Intermezzo)—Blackboard RESERVE

  • Ah, quanto mi sta male/Son imbrogliato io (Simple & accomponaied recitative/da capo aria)—CD7, tracks 1-6

K) NAWM 102—Johann Adolf Hasse, Cleofide (Italian opera seria)—Blackboard RESERVE

  • Act II, scene 9: Digli ch’io son fidele (Da capo aria)—CD7, tracks 7-11

Study Questions on J-K:

  • 11. How is Uberto’s aria (J) typical of Italian comic opera? How is the aria from Hasse’s Cleofide (K) typical of opera seria? Which would you rather listen to?
  • 12. How are these two arias (J & K) different from late Baroque arias by Handel or Bach?

Late Classic Reform Opera

L) NAWM 104—Christoph Willibald Gluck, Orfeo ed Euridice (Reform opera (Opera seria))

  • Act II, scene 1 (excerpt)—CD7, tracks 16-21

Study Questions on L:

  • 13. How is this Gluck example different from early Classic comic opera? Is it radically different or just a little different? How is the orchestra used? Does it merely accompany the singers? How does Gluck use instrumentation, texture, and contrast to heighten the dramatic effect?

Mozart Opera

M) NAWM 117—Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Don Giovanni (Opera—dramma giocoso)

  • Act I, scene 1 (aria & ensemble)—CD8, tracks 36-39
  • Act I, scene 2 (recitative)—CD8, track 40

N) Mozart, Le Nozze di Figaro DVD—RESERVE VIDEO 782.1 N961

  • Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Le Nozze di Figaro (opera buffa)
    • Act II, No. 15
      • “O guarda il demonietto!” (recitative)—track 32
      • “Tutto è come il lasciai” (recitative)—track 33
    • Act II, No. 16: Finale
      • “Esci, omai, garzon malnato”—track 34
      • “Signori, di fuori son già i suonatori”—track 35
    • “Drop-the-laser-beam” on Classicism Exam!

O) Mozart, The Magic Flute DVD—RESERVE VIDEO 782.1 T846

  • Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Die Zauberflöte (Singspiel)
    • Act II, No. 21. Finale (excerpt)
      • “Pa–Pa–Pa” (duet)—track 22 (on DVD, Papagena at last—1:51:02 to 1:54:24)

Study Questions on M-O:

  • 14. What’s funny about example M? (Think words, music, concepts—what’s really going on?) What’s not funny? (Donna Anna and her father are definitely not smiling…) Is it possible to tell if Don Giovanni forced himself on Donna Anna or if it was concensual? What message is Mozart conveying? How can Mozart fit all of this into the same scene? (Could Baroque music depict this?)
  • 15. What makes Marriage of Figaro funny? Do Figaro and Susanna behave as you would expect servants to act in the 18th century? Why or why not? Who gains the upper hand in this battle of wits? How? What is at stake?
  • 16. How effective is this Marriage of Figaro Act II finale? Did twenty minutes of music (without any recitative!) work out well? How would you describe the finale’s overall effect? Did it resolve all the plot twists for a satisfying ending or was it a “crescendo of confusion” that left you hanging? How would you describe it?
  • 17. What’s funny about example O? How does Magic Flute differ from dramma giocoso or opera buffa? Which is more (or less) sophisticated? What kind of audience was this written for? What general conclusions can you draw about the Singspiel genre (German-language comic opera) in relation to Italian opera?
  • 18. How do these Mozart operas compare with Pergolesi (NAWM 101)? How are they typical of (or similar to) Italian opera buffa? How are they atypical?

Return to top


Classic Sonata Form Listening Guide

It’s not so hard to follow sonata form when you tune into the feeling of stability vs. instability. Theme statements (1st, 2nd, or closing themes) sound stable, with lots of tonic. dominant, and dominant prep chords. Transitional sections (bridge and development) sound unstable, with frequent modulations and non-scale tones. The following diagrams offer two ways of visualizing a sonata form movement.

Sonata Form Arch Map


Sonata Form Tonal Map

Concerto Double-Exposition Sonata Form Tonal Map

Return to top


Sonata Form Features
—Used as the standard 1st movement form for the vast majority of Classic symphonies, string quartets and solo sonatas
—Evolved from Baroque rounded binary form
—Divides into three sections: Exposition, Development, and Recapitulation
—A dynamic, dramatic form defined primarily by its tonal contour: in the Exposition, tonic and dominant (or relative major) tonal areas separated by a modulation; in the Development, modulations and instability; and in the Recapitulation, stability and a reaffirmation of the tonic key

Slow Introduction
—An optional section in a very slow tempo that provides a grand or sometimes an eerie beginning to the movement
—By contrast to this introduction, Theme 1 sounds even more lively!
—May be stable or unstable, and it often begins in the parallel minor key!
—N.B.: this is not part of the Exposition; the Exposition begins at the new, faster tempo marking
 
Exposition
Theme 1
A stable theme in the tonic key
Bridge Unstable section beginning in the tonic key, then modulating and ending on a dominant chord in the new key (either dominant or relative major)
Theme 2 Stable theme that often contrasts sharply with Theme 1, but in the “wrong” key, the first theme we hear in this new key, often repeated (but watch out for Haydn symphonies that re-use Theme 1 to establish the new key!)
Closing Theme
Stable, final-sounding section (still in the new key) that uses and often repeats cadential figures

Development
“Body” of the Development
Often extremely unstable, characterized by frequent modulations, fragmentation of themes from the Exposition, and recombination of motives from those themes, often in a more polyphonic texture
Retransition Final passage of the Development hovers around the dominant (or leading tone) chord in the original key, preparing for the Recapitulation’s return to tonic
 
Recapitulation
Theme 1
Basically the same as in the Exposition, but may be shortened or reorchestrated for grander effect
Bridge May be similar to or completely different than the Exposition’s bridge; though it doesn’t need to modulate here, it often pretends to, but then ends on a dominant chord in the original key
Theme 2
Often literally the same as Theme 2 in the Exposition, but now transposed to the original key
Closing Theme
Also often literally the same as Theme 2 in the Exposition, but now transposed to the original key; the ending
 
Coda
An optional section designed to end with more finality than the Closing Theme provides
—Usually emphasizes cadential progressions, but sometimes begins with a developmental section
—Stable theme in the tonic key
—N.B.: this is not part of the Recapitulation; it begins after the Closing Theme ends
—The easiest way to find the measure where the Closing Theme ends and the Coda begins is to compare (measure by measure) the Closing Theme from the Exposition with the Closing Theme from the Recapitulation; most of the time, they are the same length. Anything beyond that is Coda!

Return to top


Extra Credit Listening—

Buehler Library RESERVE
  • VIDEO 782.1 C388—Haydn, Symphony No. 92 DVD (Harnoncourt)
  • MCD H415/B94g—Haydn, Symphonies Nos. 94, 100, and 104 (Goodman)
  • MCD M939 K543n—Mozart, Symphonies Nos. 39 & 41
  • MCDROM M939 K456w—Mozart, String Quartet in D, K. 465 CD-ROM
  • MCD J93f, v. 3—Mozart & Schubert String Quartets (Juilliard Quartet)
  • MCD M939 K456h—Mozart, Piano Concertos K. 456 & 459 (Levin)
  • MCD M939/K482b—Mozart, Piano Concertos K. 482 & 488 (Barenboim)
  • MCD M939c—Mozart, Piano Concertos K. 467 & 595 (Perahia)
  • VIDEO 780.92 M939—Mozart, Symphonies 40 & 41 DVD (Muti)
  • MCD M939 K527—Mozart, Don Giovanni
  • MCD M939 K620g—Mozart, Die Zauberflöte (Magic Flute)
  • VIDEO 782.1 T846—Mozart, The Magic Flute
  • VIDEO 782.1 N961—Mozart, Le Nozze di Figaro (Marriage of Figaro)
Return to top

Created 1/26/12 by Mark Harbold—last updated 1/31/12